Australia’s inbound tourism growth is almost triple the world average of 3.9%. Much of this growth came from NE Asia and North America with China, South Korea, Japan and the USA among Australia’s fastest growing source markets.
But while tourism looks bright for Australia, this rapid growth has revealed underlying problems. There is a significant shortage of trained and qualified people to service the growing number of tourists, and infrastructure in parts of the industry has failed to keep up with tourism demand.
If Australia wants to continue enjoying the benefits of its tourism boom, it needs to address these issues.
A Tourism Australia report, warned back in 2015 that there was a shortage of 38,000 people in all areas of the tourism industry. If there were no major policy changes this could blow out to over 120,000 people by 2020.
You may think that tourism is made up of unskilled jobs such as waiters, room cleaners, kitchen staff and bellhops. Important as these jobs are, the tourism industry requires people at all skill levels. These include airline pilots, tour guides, computer programmers and a myriad of other jobs. For every ten unskilled positions there is also one at management and supervisory level.
Many of the 2,000 tourism businesses surveyed in the Tourism Australia research found it difficult to recruit appropriately experienced or trained staff to fill vacancies.
The industry has addressed some of these issues by hiring or retaining more experienced employees, some of whom had come out of retirement. Many unskilled positions are being filled by foreign workers on 457 visas and there is a high reliance on working holiday visa holders, especially for many of the industry’s seasonal jobs.
But there is an urgent need to upgrade and promote tourism and hospitality training at all levels of education. The TAFE sector, which has traditionally been a major source of vocational training, has seen its funding cut by successive governments in recent years. TAFE’s place has been largely taken by high fee private colleges. However, many of their students are international students and a significant portion of them will take their new skills back to their home countries.
There are three urgent infrastructure needs in the Australian tourism industry.
First, there is a shortage of upmarket (4 & 5 star) hotel accommodation in Australia’s major gateway and business cities (Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane and Perth). While the overall hotel occupancy rate for Australia is about 65% the occupancy rates for luxury and business hotels in these key cities is closer to 90%. This means during peak periods it is almost impossible to find a 4-5 star hotel room in a major CBD.
The shortage of upmarket accommodation has been a contributing factor to a stagnant market in business travel to Australia. This is a stark contrast to the strong growth of holiday travel.
Second, according to Cruise Lines International Association the Australian cruise market has grown more than six fold in the past decade. This rapid growth has created a shortage of port facilities, especially in Australia’s most popular cruise embarkation and destination port, Sydney. Unless Sydney is able to offer a third dedicated cruise terminal soon, growth opportunities will be limited.
Finally, a longer term issue is the glacial progress towards a high speed rail link between Brisbane and Melbourne via Sydney and Canberra. To date, Australia’s major airports have successfully managed the growth of international and domestic passenger numbers and new airline services. However, high speed rail could relieve pressure on airports. Australia has spent decades debating the pros and cons of high speed rail, while rail China builds 1,500 kms of track every year.
What to do About it
Tourism is a balancing act between creating demand and ensuring the supply of both human resources and infrastructure. Clearly, there is still much to achieve to strike the balance.
The private sector is chipping away at the shortage of upmarket accommodation in Australia’s major cities, with several thousand new hotel rooms due to come online over the next few years. However, unlike many of Australia’s neighbours, such as Singapore and Malaysia, Australia offers few development and investment incentives to develop accommodation.
Both federal and state governments need to invest more resources in promoting tourism careers, tourism education and training at both the vocational and higher education levels. This includes means-based assistance for young Australians to undertake training and education at nationally accredited training and educational institutions.
Tourism has been treated by Australian governments as a cash cow, with little investment. The fragmented nature of the industry has meant it has lacked the political clout of industries such as mining or agriculture.
As one of Australia’s fastest growing sectors, tourism is long overdue for a level of government investment which matches its contribution to economic growth and employment.